Published October 29, 2026

One Phone Call Earned This Nashville Seller $54,000 More

Author Avatar

Written by Team FYKES Realty

One Phone Call Earned This Nashville Seller $54,000 More

 

Instant offers on your home are a useful tool, but a short call with our team can show you every option on the table first.

What if one phone call could put an extra $54,000 in your home sale? For an investor we recently helped in Nashville, that’s exactly what it did.

His name is Steve, and his situation is more common than you might think. He owned an investment property and wasn’t sure what to do with it. His property management company couldn’t rent it, so he started looking at his options. Like a lot of owners, he reached out to one of those instant offer companies you see on billboards and in your inbox, and he got a number back.

But something held him back from signing. He wasn’t fully convinced selling that way was the right move, so he called us for a second opinion.

A second opinion changed his entire outcome. We looked at the property, talked through what it could actually do on the open market, and got his home under contract. No extra work on his end, no extra hassle. When the numbers came in, he walked away with $54,000 more than the instant offer promised.

Instant offers are a tool, not the whole toolbox. We use them for our clients all the time, and for the right situation they’re genuinely useful. If you need speed and certainty, an instant offer can be the right call. The problem isn’t the tool. It’s using it without knowing what else is on the table, because an instant offer will very likely come in below what you’d get on the open market.

 

“He almost took the instant offer until one phone call put $54,000 back in his pocket.”

 

The extra time is usually worth it. For Steve, the second opinion cost him roughly a week and a half of holding the property, time he could have skipped by taking the instant offer. He might have decided the faster route made more sense for him, and that would have been a fine choice. Instead, he decided $54,000 more in his pocket was the better one. The point was never that one option beats the other. It’s that he got to decide with all the information in front of him.

That’s what we want for you too. Whether you’re weighing an instant offer or just want to know what your property could really net, we’ll shoot you straight about what needs to be done, what you could walk away with, and which path fits your goals. We can even show you both the on-market price and the instant offer price side by side.

Don’t miss out on having all the information before you make one of your biggest financial decisions. Call or text us at 615-315-9223, email us at homes@fykesgroup.com, or visit us at fykesrealtygroup.com. We’d love to help you find out what your home is really worth.

Agent profile image in chat bubble
Agent profile image in chat header

Tiffany Fykes

Team Leader, Realtor | FYKES Realty Group | Tiffany Fykes

Agent profile image in message

or another way